Debate Assesment Rubric

Debate Assesment Rubric

1.     Motion : This House should ban cigarettes from society

a.     Opening Government

They are agree because cigarettes causes many disease and negative impact to environment. Cigarettes also give bad impacts to the second hand smoker.

The reason to use cigarettes as a stress reliefer is not relevant. There is many ways to relief stress in a healthy way. Other people have rights to live healthy

b.     Opening Opposition

They did not agree because cigarettes can relief stress. Its their right to use cigarettes for stress reliefer. The person itself can smoke in a private room

Smoking for some people is the only way to relief stress. We cant also band cigarettes for causing a pollution, because there are many factor of air pollution

c.     Closing Government

For introverts people, they can find other way to relief stress such as doing their hobby

We should ban cigarettes from the society slowly, in a step by step.

d.     Closing Opposition

We should not ban cigarettes because it supports the nation’s income in a huge number. It will be an opposite of the result that we hope if we ban the cigarettes.

Cigarettes are benefitial for many sector such as economy, crime percentage, etc.

Winner : Opposition

Reason : Because the opposition can give us a more in depth arguments with facts.

2.     Motion : This house would ban all pornography

a.     Opening Government

They are agree because pornography gave us many downside to our mind, such as IQ decreases and give addiction to ourself

There are many ways to learn the sexual education in a right way. We are agree that we have freedom, but every freedom has a limitation in it.

b.     Opening Opposition

They didn’t agree because it’s a fine thing for the human. We need it also for the sexual education

Porn can also give relief stress and can decrease sexual harassment number

c.     Closing Government

In fact porn can stimulate us to do sexual harassment. And porn also are too exposed for the children

So we can learn sex education in a better way, porn makes bad effect for people

d.     Closing Opposition

We should not ban it because it’s one of the largest economical industries, it is the place for many people do their job

Banning its not an effective way for stopping people o watch porn. It can raise the rape rate. So what we can do is to repair the regulation

Winner : Opposition

Reason : Because the opposition give us more fact

3.     Motion : The reality shows bring more harm

a.     Opening Government

They are agree because a lot of viewers cannot differ between the good and bad thing. It’s also can distract student from doing their homework and study.

It is actually faked, they are just following the scripts, tha goal is to get many viewers

b.     Opening Opposition

There are many positive side such as it can entertain us. The reality shows can also raise a lot of money.

c.     Closing Government

There are a lots of way to show our talent. The reality shows also have more harm because a lot of children watching it not under their parents control

d.     Closing Opposition

Reality shows can make the audiences entertained, it can also be a charity fund raiser. It can attracts many viewers. And it has many positive impact. It can makes our day better. And a lot of the negative impacts are actually not our fault.

Winner : Opposition

Reason : Because the opposition can give us a more facts and a more relevant opinion

Additional Task

Motion : The use of handphone in the classroom

My opinion about it : I agree to allow tha use of handphones in the classroom, because with the phone we can get and search more information about the material. The phone also usefull when we have to copy the note about the lesson. We just have to use it wisely